When trying to maintain a quiet and peaceful home, reducing the amount of noise can be exceedingly difficult as you have to worry about both outside and inside sources. That said, you have far more control over the noise generated inside of your home than you do the noise made outside of it.
Since you generally cannot effectively remove the noise made outside of your home, your only recourse is to find a way to block or dampen it. That said, where you dampen the noise often matters as much, if not more, than how you dampen outside noise with every opening presenting a way for more noise to seep into your home.
That is why we put together a list of the 5 best soundproof draft guard for door reviews of 2020, highlighting what each one does best. We also provide a helpful buyer’s guide and answer the topic’s most pressing questions, so you can find a draft guard to provide you the most peace and quiet possible.
Best Sound Proof Draft Guard for Door Reviews
Best Seller: Suptikes Door Draft Stopper Under Door Seal for Exterior/Interior Doors, Door Sweep Strip Under Door Draft Blocker, Soundproof Door Bottom Weather Stripping, 2″ W x 39″ L, White
- 【NO MORE GAPS】 - 2" Width x 39" Length, Fits Gaps up to 1 Inch. Self-adhesive door draft blocker for extra large gaps exterior/interior...
- 【SAVE MONEY and ENERGY】- In winter and summer, draft stopper prevent the leakage of air conditioning and heating, make your room more...
- 【MULTIPLE PROTECTION】 - Guard against drafts, odors and noise; block out under-door light. Our door weather stripping makes your home...
Suptikes is a tricky company to gauge as they do not have much of an online presence and the presence they do have is embedded with potential security risks. While this definitely raises some alarms, the company has been around for almost half a decade and specializes exclusively in doorway draft sweeps.
It is worth noting that the effectiveness of the Suptikes draft guard will heavily depend on how well you install it, though even the best installation will only dampen the sound so much. Keep in mind that this draft guard is the best seller, but that does not necessarily make it the best performing option.
On the other hand, the Suptikes draft guard is easily the most effective model on our list for controlling the climate and performing the function of its name: guarding against drafts. Of course, if you want it to dampen outside noise, you need to make sure that the door is clean and you install it precisely to avoid any additional gaps.
One great thing about the Suptikes draft guard is that it can fit snugger than most other models without also impeding the action of the door. In fact, its 2” height makes it effective for blocking gaps of up to 1” tall and its 39” length is more than enough to fit most sizes of a door with a little bit extra for customization.
While the installation may be a bit trickier with the Suptikes draft guard, it is at least an exceptionally inexpensive option. Unfortunately, the silicone material may be great at blocking drafts but it can also draw rodents that like to gnaw on the otherwise flexible and durable material.
Features
- Easily sticks on to most standard doors with an adhesive strip
- Offers more protection than most sweeps with triple layers
- Able to adjust to various different door styles with a cuttable design
- Safe for all floor material due to silicone material
- Works with most decor, coming in 4 different colors
Verdict
The Suptikes draft guard may not be the quietest model on our list, but it does perform the other functions of a draft guard better than most of the competition. Keep in mind, the performance of this draft guard depends heavily on how well you install it which is easily the most difficult installation on our list.
Pros
- Features a triple-layer design
- Is more stable
- Excellent for drafts
- Easy to customize
Cons
- Not the easiest installation
- Does not stop rodents
Top Pick: DECOREALM Heavy Duty Door Draft Stopper and Blocker, Sound Proof Draft Guard for Doors and Windows, Decorative Cylinder Provides Door Insulation and Weather Stripping for Doors (Black, 36 Inches)
- The Original Fashionable Door Pillow: DECOREALM is the original developer of the draft, noise, and smell reducing door pillow. With our...
- Designed and Crafted To Last: Our under door blocker is designed for durability and sturdiness. This high-end, uniquely designed door...
- Created for Ultimate Convenience: This door wind guard has a double satin handle so you can hang it in the closet, on a coat rack or door...
DECOREALM is one of the newer companies on our list at only a couple of years, but it has a surprisingly consistent online presence. It is also worth noting that while the company has recently branched off into a couple of additional consumer goods, it started and still focuses primarily on draft guards.
The DECOREALM draft guard stands atop our list as potentially the quietest option we encountered thanks to a couple of features, but it is also one of the least convenient. In terms of its sound dampening quality, this is a thick pillow-type of draft guard that employs a large 3 ½” x 36” profile.
This is easily the thickest entry on our list and the heaviest too at 3 ½ lbs, but its 36” profile and pillow design mean that it will not fit flush with non-standard door sizes. Still, this draft guard continues to provide superior sound-dampening qualities thanks to the inclusion of ceramic beads for the fill.
Keep in mind, the ceramic beads not only provide some of the best sound dampening we encountered, but they are also exceptionally good at blocking out the cold or heat. Still, the pillow design of the DECOREALM draft guard means that you will constantly have to readjust it every time you open the door.
On the other hand, this is also the only type of draft guard that you can remove entirely if the situation calls for it and is the easiest to move from door to another. It also does not hurt that the exterior is made of wool and polyester so that it is strong and machine washable while also adding an additional layer of insulation.
Features
- Keeps out noise, drafts, and odors with a ceramic bead fill
- Fits most standard doors with a 3 ½” x 36” profile
- Can be cleaned with a machine-washable sleeve
- Excellent design in 4 colors with accented ends and handles
- Easily stow away on a coat rack with dual handles
Verdict
The DECOREALM draft guard has the potential to be the quietest entry on our list thanks to a thick design and the use of ceramic beads for the fill. However, you will need to constantly readjust this draft guard, and its performance will heavily depend on how well you jam it against the door.
Pros
- Stows better than most
- 3 ½” x 36” profile
- Has a ceramic bead fill
- Easy to use
Cons
- Not the most stable
- Is not customizable
Best Value: MAXTID Door Draft Stopper White Double Sided Draft Guard Sound Proof Blocker Cold Air Stopper – Adjustable 32 to 38″
- MAXTID door draft stopper
- MAXTID door draft stopper
- MAXTID door draft stopper
MAXTID is another recent company that has only been around for a couple of years, though it does present a solid online presence. However, MAXTID focuses more on general consumer goods made with thick or weighted textiles than door guards or their associated products specifically.
Given that focus, you might expect the MAXTID draft guard to employ a pillow design, but this is actually the first option on our list to use the sleeve design. While there are some benefits to this type of draft guard, sound dampening is not one of its strengths– though it is not terribly in this respect.
The issue primarily comes from the fact that the MAXTID draft guard uses a foam tube to block the gap in your door which is not as good a dampening sound as many other materials. On the other hand, the sleeve design at least provides this draft two layers of protection to make up for its iffy fill material.
It is also worth noting that while the MAXTID draft guard’s foam fill may not be the best at dampening sound, it is exceptionally good at guarding against drafts. On top of that, the dual-sided sleeve design further reinforces this draft guard’s ability to prevent drafts from seeping into your home.
Of course, the MAXTID draft guard’s design is a bit of a double-edged sword as the sleeve design is one of the easiest to install that provides convenient stability. However, that convenient stability only extends to opening the door as the added bulk can impede the door’s action and make closing it more difficult.
Features
- Offers exceptional protection thanks to its sleeve design
- Fits most standard with a 1 ⅖” x 38” x 1 ⅘” profile
- Easily adjusts to fit any size door with a cuttable design
- A breeze to take care of with a machine-washable sleeve
- Works with most decor, coming in 4 different colors
Verdict
The MAXTID draft guard is not only an inexpensive option, but it is significantly easier to install than other stable options and customizes easily enough too. That said, the foam fill is not as effective at blocking out sound as it is guarding against drafts, and the sleeve design can impede the action of the door.
Pros
- Covers both sides of the door
- Easy to customize
- Easy to care for
- Has 1 ⅖” of protection
Cons
- Not the best fill
- Can impede the door
Runner Up: MAGZO Door Snake Draft Blocker 30in x 3in, Gray Noise Blocker Sound Proof Heavy Duty Bottom Insulation Keep Draft Out Multi-Function Door Draft Stopper
- ALL SEASON PROTECTION - The durable sound proof bottom door weather stripping keeps your room warmer in winter and cooler in summer. The...
- MULTI-FUNCTION DOOR SNAKE BLOCKER-The door snake blocker is dust proof, windproof, good sound insulation effect, can stop the hot and cold...
- CONVENIENT TO USE - The door draft guard is easy to install and remove. Just apply the included hook tape to your door, then stick the door...
MAGZO continues the trend of companies on our list that are fairly new, having been founded only a couple of years ago. That said, the company has a decent online presence but takes a slightly different approach in that it specializes in window and door accessories in general– though it specializes more in magnetic screens than draft guards.
The MAZGO draft guard is another pillow-type model which means it comes with many of the same benefits and drawbacks as the other pillow design we reviewed. For noise-dampening, this draft guard presents a solid option, though not the best pillow-type as it is not quite as thick as its competitor.
This is most notable when you consider its total weight which only tips the scales at 2 ⅔ pounds, though this also has to do with its materials. Rather than using an advanced material to increase its noise-dampening effects, the MAZGO draft guard goes with the tried and true polyester fill.
This material is not as good at dampening noise as more advanced materials, but it does offer a good deal of insulation. Granted, that additional draft guarding that you get from the polyester fill is somewhat lessened by the pillow design depending on how well you butt the draft guard against the door’s gap.
One thing that really stands out about the MAZGO draft guard is that they have an option sized to suit everyone’s needs which is especially important for a pillow design that you cannot customize. Even better, this is one of the few pillow draft guards we encountered that also comes with adhesive tape to help increase the design’s inherent low stability.
Features
- Keeps out noise, drafts, and odors with a polyester fill
- Fits most standard doors with a 3” x 30” profile
- Can be made more stable with the inclusion of adhesive tape
- Suitable for extra large or small doors with 7 different sizes
- Works with most decor, coming in 8 different colors
Verdict
The MAZGO draft guard is another pillow-type of draft guard but is not quite as quiet as our best options due to being a bit thinner than the other pillow model we reviewed. However, this is the only pillow door guard that we found that also includes adhesive tape for a stabler fit and comes in more sizes than any other entry.
Pros
- Can be made stable
- Is easy to care for
- Has a 3” x 30” profile
- Has more options
Cons
- Is not adjustable
- Has iffy soundproofing
Also Consider: Holikme Twin Door Draft Stopper Weather Stripping Noise Blocker Window Breeze Blocker Adjustable Door Sweeps 34inch Grey
- Easy to install: adjustable size for most homes; Please measure the gap and width of the door before purchasing and keep the door clean to...
- Large size sponge is not ordinary slender sponge, which will not move with the opening of the door
- Hook and loop fastener design, keeps foam tubes safely inside even with constant opening and closing of doors
Holikme rounds out our list and follows the trend of newer companies that have only been around for a couple of years while its online presence is middling at best. One of the odder aspects of this company is the fact that it focuses primarily on cleaning brushes designed to attach to a power drill instead of draft guards or even door-related accessories.
The Holikme draft guard is another sleeve-type that could have avoided some of the drawbacks of the sleeve design but instead opted for a less expensive approach. As such, that means that you should not expect this draft guard to dampen noise as much as some of the other options on our list.
The primary reason that the Holikme draft guard does not dampen noise as much as it could comes down to the common foam fill found in many sleeve design draft guards. Of course, like other sleeve draft guards with a foam fill, this model provides a better all-around seal than some of the other types.
In fact, the Holikme draft guard might provide the best seal on our list as not only does the sleeve design guard against drafts from both the front and back of the door, this particular entry is 2”– the thickest sleeve draft guard on our list. Also, like other sleeve draft guards, this model is easy to customize to fit your door, though it is only 34” long which is shorter than some standard door sizes.
Like other sleeve draft guards, this option can impede the action of the door, potentially more than most due to its increased thickness. Another interesting choice the Holikme draft guard made is to use cotton for the exterior material as it is machine washable and insulates well-enough but not the most durable.
Features
- Offers exceptional protection thanks to its sleeve design
- Fits most standard doors with a 2” x 34” profile
- Easily adjusts to fit any size door with a cuttable design
- A breeze to take care of with a machine-washable sleeve
- Works with most decor, coming in 8 different colors
Verdict
The Holikme draft guard is another sleeve model that offers the same great draft guarding performance as similar models but suffers a bit in the sound dampening department due to a foam fill. While this sleeve draft guard is a bit thicker than others, that tends to impede the action more without dampening sound that much better.
Pros
- Covers both sides of the door
- Is easy to customize
- Is easy to care for
- Has 2” of protection
Cons
- Not the best fill
- Can impede the door
Best Sound Proof Draft Guard for Door Buying Guide
Volume
As the qualitative topic of our list, the amount of noise that a draft guard can dampen is one of the most important factors to consider. However, it is worth remembering that the primary purpose of a draft guard is to prevent the outside air from getting inside your home and increasing your monthly central climate control cost.
That said, when considering which draft guards dampen noise the best, it is important to figure out what kind of fill the model uses. On top of the fill, the type as well as the thickness of the draft guard both play huge roles in determining how well the product will dampen outside noise.
Type
There are a couple of different types of draft guards that are more or less focused on reducing the draft with the added benefit of also dampening outside noise. If you need a draft guard for its intended purpose, you may have to weigh the effectiveness of blocking drafts against its ability to dampen noise.
- Door Sweep – This type of draft guard is the only one that does not use fabric and is significantly more focused on reducing drafts than it is in dampening noise. While this kind of draft guard can be a bit more difficult to install, it is easily the most stable type of draft guard on our list.
- Pillow Jamb – Taking the opposite approach from its predecessor, the pillow jamb is arguably the least effective draft guard at reducing drafts since it can be more difficult to get a flush fit. However, what it lacks in draft guardian performance it more than makes up for in sound dampening as thick fills do more to block outside noise than any other design.
- Door Sleeve – While the design is different from the prior two, the door sleeve splits the difference in terms of draft guarding and sound-dampening performance. The door sleeve is better at guarding against drafts than dampening outside noise, but its design also tends to impede your ability to open and close the door.
Materials
Outside of the type, the materials tend to have the biggest impact on how well a draft guard performs at its various tasks. Two draft guards that employ the same design can still produce different results depending on the materials chosen– not to mention these materials can also influence the product’s general durability.
- Silicone – Silicone is used exclusively for door sweeps, but it is an ideal material for this purpose as it is both durable and flexible. This allows the door sweep to be installed as low to the floor as possible without having to worry about it catching and impeding the door’s action. The main issue with silicone is that places with rodent populations may find the pests chewing on the material.
- Cotton – Cotton is used almost exclusively for the exterior of both pillow jambs and door sleeves since it absorbs liquid more than most other materials which can be tricky at the threshold of a door leading outside. Cotton is a decent and inexpensive material, but it is not as durable as synthetic fibers nor does it insulate as well as thicker natural fibers.
- Wool – Much like cotton, wool is used almost exclusively for the exterior material, though it tends to enclose pillow jambs and not door sleeves. Part of the reason for this is that wool absorbs water as much as other natural fibers and can also suffer from durability issues. However, wool is superior to cotton in that it offers more insulation and guards against drafts better while also dampening sound more.
- Polyester – Polyester and other synthetic fibers are a cheap alternative to natural fibers that tend to perform better as a draft guard which exposes the fabric to more stresses. Polyester is naturally water-resistant which makes it perfect for both pillow jambs and door sleeves while also sporting better abrasion durability. Polyester insulates about as well as cotton but not as good as wool and dampens noise along that comparison too.
- Foam – Foam is used exclusively as a fill material and almost always for door sleeves since you want a material that will give to the door without permanently deforming. It is arguably one of the worst-performing fills on our list, but the fact that the door sleeve employs two foam fills helps account for this natural drawback. Foam is significantly better at guarding against drafts than it is dampening noise, but it is also easy to cut for customized fits.
- Ceramic – Ceramic is another material used exclusively for fills, though it is almost always only used for pillow jamb fills and comes in the form of beads. In terms of performance, ceramic is easily the best fill on our list as the material is naturally waterproof, insulates better than any other material, and also dampens noise more than any other material. The main issue with a ceramic fill is that it is often significantly more expensive than cheaper materials used.
FAQ’s
What Makes a Draft Guard Soundproof?
It is worth noting that no draft guard is going to be completely soundproof, but they can offer varying degrees of sound dampening properties to help keep your home quiet and peaceful. That said, what makes one type of draft guard soundproof will not necessarily carry over to the next draft guard depending on the type.
In fairness, no one type is inherently superior to another, though one of the more important factors to consider is how well the draft guard seals the gap at the base of the door. While some types are better at this than others, all of them can provide a solid seal, though the sleeve models tend to be the easiest.
Outside of the seal, most draft guards also include some kind of fill that is used to dampen the noise with denser fills blocking out more noise than lighter fills. However, this also comes with the downside that denser fills are rarely customizable which means you have to make sure the draft guard fits perfectly before choosing it.
Which type is Right for Me?
When it comes to picking a soundproof draft guard, one of the more obvious choices comes down to the type which comes in three options: a sweep, a pillow, or a sleeve. Which one you choose tends to hinge more on convenience factors and your potential handiwork skills than anything else as most types can perform reasonably well.
The easiest type to customize, install, and maintain is the sleeve type as this is the only type of draft guard that covers both sides of the door and slips under the gap. However, this is not always the most soundproof option due to a poor fill material and while customizable, cannot be made to fit larger doors after customized to fit smaller ones.
The sweep draft guard is your basic door sweep that can be added to any existing door and does a great job at stopping drafts. Its soundproofing quality is middling with installation being a bit trickier, but arguably the biggest knock against it is that rodents often enjoy chewing through this type.
The last type is the pillow type which can have great results depending on your setup and is the only type that does not affix to the door in any way. Instead, you butt the pillow draft guard against the opening, making this a good option to prevent the door from being impeded but can have subpar results if you are not diligent.
Things to Look For?
Outside of the type and soundproofing qualities, there is not really all that much to a soundproof draft guard to sway your decision one way or another. Most of the factors that will influence these factors are inherently tied to the type, though there are a couple of different aspects to consider.
For example, doors and doorways tend to get a bit messy as they present a literal threshold between your controlled interior and nature outdoors. As such, cleaning your draft guard will be a periodic requirement that can be made easier or more difficult depending on the materials used in its construction.
It is also worth noting that while doors come in a number of different standard sizes, some draft guards are able to customize their size– though often only once. Finally, some draft guards affix themselves to the door which makes them more convenient but can potentially impede the door’s action while those that remain unaffixed require constant repositioning but allow for an easy action.
Conclusion
Ultimately, the best soundproof door draft guard will depend as much on how convenient and effective of a draft guard you want your choice to be as much as how much it dampens outside noise. The Suptikes draft guard serves as one of the better draft guards, but it is not ideal for dampening noise and useless against rodents.
The DECOREALM draft guard presents the best noise-dampening qualities with a thick, ceramic bead fill, but is less convenient than other options. The MAXTID draft guard skirts the line by offering solid draft guarding performance with okay sound-dampening qualities due to the foam fill.
The MAZGO draft guard is another solid sound-dampening draft guard, though not the quietest– but it does allow for a stable or portable design. Finally, the Holikme draft guard presents one of the quietest sleeve draft guards we encountered, but the thicker foam fill also impedes your door’s action more than any other option we reviewed.